Shooting the Messenger: Sure-Fire Help for Your Competition

"Don't shoot the messenger" sticky note on cork board Economists and other experts will champion the positive implications of competition in business.

Be it hard products or intangible services, competition in the marketplace tends to benefit both the consumer and the enterprise with purchase options, innovation, price/cost influences and other considerations.

As we all know, competition in healthcare was one of the driving factors in the Affordable Care Act. And, as we also know, the unintended (and often negative) consequences of competition in health care marketing have been a major upheaval among physician practices, medical groups and hospitals.

It’s a whole new ballgame for most provider businesses, and the startling wakeup call is that many practices aren’t reacting well to the unexpected and steady erosion of market share. And what’s even more troubling is—despite the seismic shift in the landscape—some organizations would prefer to believe that continuing to do what they’ve done in the past is going to produce different and better results.

You can’t play a new game by old rules…

With frightening regularity, we will encounter a shrinking healthcare business that intellectually sees the competition, but emotionally rejects the need to market aggressively and defensively. For those situations—where they would prefer to shoot the messenger—here is a reality check:

We can assure you that your biggest competitors

do not share your misgivings about marketing.

 Not only are they going to continue to invest in winning new business from you, they are actually thrilled that you aren’t spending anything to slow their success or enhance your prospects of your own survival.

Your competition is perfectly willing to let you to do little or nothing (as you have done in the past.) It’s a big part of the reason that the competition is winning.

What to do instead…

One course is to do nothing and let the competitive tide continue to erode your business. It’s not pleasant news to absorb, but as a responsible marketing advisor, I can only offer the advice and direction that I believe they need. But at the end of the day, if “the patient” would rather shoot the messenger the outcome will continue to be disappointing.

The better alternative is to decide to chart a new course in this new environment. And while the road ahead may still be bumpy, consider the advice of Peter Drucker: “Whenever you see a successful business, someone once made a courageous decision.”

For more on this topic, read: Competition is Increasing Rapidly and Dramatically, and Underestimate the Competition: Critical Medical Advertising Mistake #9.

Give us a call if we can help. But please don’t shoot the messenger.

Stewart Gandolf, MBA

Stewart Gandolf
Chief Executive Officer & Creative Director at Healthcare Success
Over the years Stewart has personally marketed and consulted for over 1,457 healthcare clients, ranging from private practices to multi-billion dollar corporations. Additionally, he has marketed a variety of America’s leading companies, including Citicorp, J. Walter Thompson, Grubb & Ellis, Bally Total Fitness, Wells Fargo and Chase Manhattan. Stewart co-founded our company, and today acts as Chief Executive Officer and Creative Director. He is also a frequent author and speaker on the topic of healthcare marketing. His personal accomplishments are supported by a loving wife and two beautiful daughters.



Your proposal will include:

Competitor Intel Icon
Competitor Intel
Recommendations Icon
Our Pricing Icon
Our Pricing

...and much more!

“Despite practicing in a hyper-competitive market, our new-patient counts are double what they were for the same time period last year. Hiring Healthcare Success was one of the best business decisions I have ever made.”

Headshot of Jonathan Calure
– Jonathan Calure, MD

List of recent conversions